Welcome to The Cheese Scale, where we embark on a journey to rate the cheesiness of popular romance novels. From heart-fluttering tales to over-the-top melodramas, these books have captured the hearts of readers around the world. Join us as we explore their cheesy essence, providing ratings from 1 (minimal cheesiness) to 5 (the cheesiest) on the Cheese Scale.
The Rating System
There’s definitely no science involved in coming up with the ratings for the book recommendations below. They are, however, graded on several factors common to cheesy romance novels. The novels will be rated based on their bigness or use of exaggerate declarations, how much they lean towards the melodramatic, their reliance on common tropes and clichés, their use of dramatic dialogue, and the emotional intensity.
Twilight by Stephanie Meyer
This beloved vampire romance earns a high cheese rating due to its over-the-top elements. The intense emotions, sweeping declarations of love, and supernatural elements contribute to its dramatic and cheesy appeal. From Bella and Edward’s undying love to the heightened stakes of their forbidden relationship, Twilight embodies the epitome of melodramatic romance.
Fifty Shades of Grey by E. L. James
With its exploration of unconventional relationships, dominance, and eroticism, Fifty Shades of Grey takes the cheese factor to the extreme. The intense and passionate encounters between Anastasia and Christian, coupled with the dramatic narrative, create a recipe for high cheesiness. The over-the-top erotic scenes, emotional rollercoasters, and the sheer extravagance of their relationship contribute to its maximum cheese rating.
The Notebook by Nicholas Sparks
While The Notebook has its fair share of romantic moments, it strikes a balance between tender and cheesy. The enduring love story of Noah and Allie, the portrayal of love across social class differences, and the emotional depth earn it a moderate cheese rating. The heartfelt declarations, poignant scenes, and nostalgic narrative elements add a touch of cheesiness, but it never goes overboard.
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
This classic romance is known for its wit, social class dynamics, and the triumph of love over obstacles. While it has its romantic moments, Austen’s elegant writing and memorable characters keep the cheese factor relatively low. The clever banter, the gradual development of affection between Elizabeth and Darcy, and the exploration of societal expectations add a subtle touch of cheesiness without overwhelming the story.
Bridget Jones’ Diary by Helen Fielding
Filled with relatable dating mishaps and humorous observations, Bridget Jones’ Diary provides a modern romantic comedy with a moderate cheese rating. Bridget’s endearing quirks, her quest for love, and the ups and downs of her romantic escapades add a delightful touch of cheesiness. While it embraces some romantic clichés, it remains light-hearted and relatable, striking a balance between comedy and genuine romantic moments.
The Rosie Project by Graeme Simsion
This charming novel about an unconventional love story between Don Tillman and Rosie keeps the cheese factor minimal. The focus on quirky characters, the exploration of acceptance and personal growth, and the genuine emotional connection between Don and Rosie earn it a low rating on the Cheese Scale. While it has its heartwarming moments, it remains grounded and relatable without succumbing to over-the-top cheesiness.
The Hating Game by Sally Thorne
With its enemies-to-lovers trope, witty banter, and undeniable chemistry, The Hating Game embraces a high level of cheesiness. The playful interactions, intense emotions, and sweeping romantic gestures between Lucy and Joshua bring a deliciously cheesy flavor to the story. Their love-hate dynamic and the high-stakes tension of their office rivalry contribute to its substantial cheese rating.
Me Before You by Jojo Moyes
Moyes tackles sensitive themes and emotional depth in the novel. The heartfelt romance between Louisa and Will has moments of cheesiness. Their transformative journey of love, self-discovery, and acceptance earns this novel a moderate cheese rating. The emotional intensity, the grand gestures of love, and the exploration of life’s complexities add a touch of cheese while maintaining a balance of depth and heartfelt romance.
The Wedding Date by Jasmine Guillory
This contemporary romance follows Alexa and Drew as they navigate a fake relationship turned real. The light-hearted banter, charming characters, and romantic tension contribute to a mildly cheesy yet enjoyable reading experience. While it incorporates romantic tropes and predictable moments, it remains relatively grounded, keeping the cheese factor at a moderate level.
The Kiss Quotient by Helen Hoang
Hoang created a world in a diverse and engaging romance that explores themes of self-discovery and acceptance. While it includes steamy moments and romantic tropes, the genuine emotional connection and character development keep the cheese factor at a moderate level. It strikes a balance between depth and lighthearted romance, offering a heartwarming and engaging love story.
From the intense drama of vampires to the awkwardly endearing quirks of modern-day love stories, these books offer something for every romance enthusiast. Whether you prefer a cheesy escape or a more nuanced emotional journey, these novels cater to different tastes on the Cheese Scale. Embrace the cheese and indulge in the guilty pleasure of these heartwarming tales of love.
Do you enjoy romance? Check these out!
Rather read something a little more… adult? Here’s your guide!