How To Make Your Halloween Magical: Secondhand Costume Edition

Want to win a costume contest, but you’re on a tight budget? These 5 hacks will have you looking amazing for Halloween without breaking the bank.

Just For Fun Pop Culture
Two people are wearing white sheets with glasses on in the dark. A bright lavender BOOKSTR logo is in the top right hand corner.

I love to dress up, so Halloween is my favorite holiday. It checks all the boxes: cool outfits, a socially acceptable time to eat tons of candy, and the spookiest vibes. But the prices are through the roof whenever you go looking for a generic Spirit Halloween costume. That’s why secondhand shopping is the way to go. I’ll share my ideas for creating an epic, bookish ensemble while also keeping costs low.

Pinterest Boards

A person at a desk holds up a phone that has a "Welcome to Pinterest" screen pulled up.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

Pinterest is one of the best creative hubs out there. It’s brimming with ideas, which makes it perfect for the planning stage. Browse through Pinterest boards to get a feel for costume choices and how to execute them. You can create your own collection of pins that serve as your inspiration.

Borrow From Friends/Family

Two dozen colorful pieces of clothing are hung on a rack with wooden hangers.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

A good piece of advice is to borrow what you can! So many times while putting together a look you’re missing one thing that could easily be in someone else’s closet. Ask around! If sizing is an issue, there are always ways to temporarily alter it for the night. Just make sure you leave it in good condition so there’s no arguments. Sometimes it takes a village to form a costume and that’s okay!

Get Crafty

Crafting supplies- scissors, colored pencils, markers, paint brushes and rulers are kept in silver containers.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

This is where it pays to be crafty. Whatever you don’t have for an outfit, you can make. Whether you’re good at sewing, embroidery, makeup, or literally anything, it becomes an asset around Halloween time. All it takes is a little imagination and some prayers. Use unsuspecting things around the house, like cardboard. This also helps if you’re an avid collector of odd items like me. Let YouTube be your guide, and you’ll be set.

Reuse From Previous Years

A little over a dozen costumes are hung on two silver racks. The hangers are green and the background is a bright yellow.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

If you’ve been at the costume game for a while, chances are you have a pile of old ones. It’s time to get a second use out of them. Certain accessories or garments could easily be turned into something useful for your latest creation. For instance, a Little Red Riding Hood cape could become a superhero cape. Your current stash could inform your decision of what to be as well.

Locate Your Nearest Thrift Shop

A dilapidated black and white thrift store sign hangs over a shop front. The background is cloudy.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

The amazing things people discard is mind-boggling. Articles of clothing are just waiting to be discovered at thrift shops. It can take a bit of time to find what you’re looking for, but the affordable prices are so worth it. Also when paying for items think about how they could exist in your regular closet so they’re a gift that keeps on giving.

Creating an eye-catching costume doesn’t have to be difficult. Channel your inner scavenger and find treasures from unlikely places. If you follow these steps you’re sure to get compliments all night long!


If you need some costume ideas to get you started, check out this article.

Shop our list of Horror novels here.

FEATURED IMAGE VIA BOOKSTR / SOPHIA CIRALDO