Is Romantasy a New Concept or a Repackaged Genre?

Let’s take a closer look at everyone’s favorite genre: Romantasy. Is this a hot new trend? Or is this just a new package for an already established category?

Book Culture Fantasy Opinions Recommendations
Five different book covers are staggered on the left side of the frame. The background is a hazy purple and pink forest landscape. The books included are The Claiming of Sleeping Beauty by A.N. Roquelaure, The Iron King by Julie Kagawa, Eternity by Maggie Shayne, City of Bones by Cassandra Clare, and The Goddess Test by Aimee Carter.

Today, we want to explore a popular trend that has been burning up in the bookish realms: the Romantasy genre. Romantasy has been a hot topic on BookTok and a favorite among Bookstagrammers. But what exactly is Romantasy? In this feature, we will unpack the definition a bit more and explore where this idea originated. But we’ll also investigate if this is really a new concept at all.

A woman wearing a long white dress and a flower crown is carrying a lantern. She is standing in a cave and looking towards a green dragon. Flowers are beside her and sunlight lights up green shrubbery in the background.
IMAGE VIA CANVA

What is Romantasy?

The term “Romantasy” has been trending lately in the book world. But what is “Romantasy”? Depending on who you ask, this may be a difficult definition to pin down. But simply put it is usually the combination of the romance and fantasy genres. If you are a fan of forbidden love, enemies-to-lovers, or star-crossed lovers combined with the backdrop of a fantastical fictional universe, then the genre of Romantasy is for you!

Cover of A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas. A wolf type creature is shot by an arrow in the throat. The animal is placed against a red background. The title is in yellow text in the foreground.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

According to a blog on Reedsy outlining the details of Romantasy, the term first appeared in the Urban Dictionary in 2008. But popularity did not flare up until Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses in 2022. During the past few years since ACOTAR, there have been a slew of trendy authors and titles following the same Romantasy path, including Rebecca Yarros’ Fourth Wing.

Cover of Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros. A symbol made up of circles and clouds in the middle of the frame. Two dragons are placed within the circles. The background is gold and the title is in black text.
IMAGE VIA AMAZON

Is Romantasy Really a New Thing?

In that same blog from Reedsy, the writer quotes an interview they held with author Jennifer L. Armentrout in which she claims this new genre of Romantasy is offering readers an alternative to “high fantasy” classics from such authors as J.R.R. Tolkien and George R.R. Martin. While we all enjoy an epic Lord of the Rings story, sometimes we need a little spicy romance to keep our attention.

Two men sit in a carriage. One is wearing a wizard hat and robes while smoking a long pipe. The other is wearing a green button up shirt and overalls. There is a stone wall and greenery in the background.
IMAGE VIA NEW LINE CINEMA

But is Romantasy a new concept? As an elder millennial, I would say no. Over the years, there have been many popular series and titles that could have been considered part of this Romantasy wave. Let’s take a moment to look at a few examples from the past and how they relate to the suggested themes.

The Claiming of Sleeping Beauty by A.N. Roquelaure (a.k.a. Anne Rice)

No shade on Anne Rice, because she has produced some of the most iconic vampire and gothic horror novels of our time, but this book was on my TBR for years, until I broke down and attempted to read it — spoilers, it was not my cup of tea. However, I must say that it could be featured as one of the OG Romantasy novels, in which Rice took a well-known fairy tale and made it extremely adult. In what was supposed to be an adaption of Sleeping Beauty, Rice’s twist is to place these characters in a kingdom of BDSM and sexual fantasy. While I do appreciate a good amount of spice in my reading, the details in this feature are a bit too much.

Cover of The Claiming of Sleeping Beauty by A.N. Roquelaure. The text is white against a black background. The text is framed by gold lines.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

The Iron King by Julie Kagawa

Geared more to the young adult crowd and published in 2010, this series fits into the Romantasy genre. The main character Meghan seems to be living an ordinary teenage life. That is until she finds out that her father is a mythical faery king. Even more alarming, she finds herself in the middle of a fae war, as she is the princess of the faery kingdom. This one even adopts the ever-so-popular enemies-turn-to-lovers trope, as Meghan is romantically intertangled with an icy prince who is fighting against her. This magical, fantasy world spans ten installments within the series.

Cover of The Iron King by Julie Kagawa. The title is in gold text. There is a gold crown on the "G" and a feather on the end of the first word. Green leaves line the letters. Everything is placed against a black background.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

Eternity by Maggie Shayne

As one of my favorite Romantasy reads, this was first published back in 1998. The entire story spans three installments in The Immortals series, as readers follow along multiple generations of witches. Throughout the centuries, witch hunters have been hot on their trail, causing them pain and heartache along the way. Heavy on the themes of forbidden love and star-crossed lovers, Shayne’s stories keep readers enthralled with the perfect level of spiciness and paranormal fantasy.

Cover of Eternity by Maggie Shayne. A man and a woman are locked in a passionate embrace. The man is shirtless, while the woman wears an intricate blue and green dress. Flowers line the foreground, while a lake and trees are in the background.
IMAGE VIA AMAZON

City of Bones by Cassandra Clare

Published only a couple of years after Twilight and riding on the popularity of young adult fantasy romance, The Mortal Instruments had more to offer to its readers with its fantastic world-building, suspenseful plot twists, and romantic tension between Clary Fray and Jace the Shadowhunter. After she is attacked by a demon and her mother vanishes, Clary is immersed in the exciting world of the Shadowhunters. This series is definitely worth a re-read if it’s been a while since you’ve read it.

Cover of City of Bones by Cassandra Clare. A shirtless man with medium blonde hair is in the background. In the foreground is a dark city skyline. Light seems to radiate from the man's chest.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

The Goddess Test by Aimee Carter

Earlier in this article, we covered fantasy exploring the fairy world. This one from Carter adapts its fantasy world from inspirations of Greek mythology. Life is pretty rough for Kate. She is uprooted to live in a new neighborhood and go to a new school, while her mother is terminally ill. However, things become a bit complicated when Kate meets Henry. Henry claims to be Hades, the God of the Underworld. He also claims that he can save Kate’s mother — but with a price: Kate’s hand in marriage.

Cover of The Goddess Test by Aimee Carter. A woman is wearing a long white dress. She has her hands placed on her stomach and her legs tucked in. She lays on top of green leaves.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

As we take this trip down memory lane to revisit some of our favorite fantasy romances, it is evident that the Romantasy genre is nothing new. But we are glad that it is seeing its trendy revival.


For more suggestions on books in fairy universes, check out 5 Fantastic Fae Reads With Sensational Seasonal Settings.

For even more romance fantasy picks, explore our bookshelf Fantasy Lovers Paradise: Epics, Romances, and More!

FEATURED IMAGE VIA BOOKSTR / MONICA MENDEZ