Great Gift Ideas for the Thriller and Mystery Connoisseurs

What should you give your mystery and thriller obsessed loved ones this holiday? Read on to look at some gift ideas your friend will love!

Book Culture Gift Guides
Featured image of a mystery board with a gift list and a detective bear with a magnifying glass looking at a stack of presents and a present tree behind the bear.

With the holidays here and the Christmas spirit filling every mall and store, it’s also the time for your nerves to skyrocket. It can be exhausting to find the perfect present for your loved ones. For book lovers, any good book will do. We can all testify to this fact. But if you want to go further in the gift-giving department, what would you give them? If your friend is a mystery lover who seeks the chilling thrills of solving a murder, then you’ve come to the right place. Here are some gift-giving ideas to spark your friend even further into their mind-solving skills and meticulous attention to detail.

Sherlock Holmes Dress-Up Kit

A deerstalker hat that Sherlock is known for wearing with a magnifying glass and a wooden pipe as part of a Sherlock Homes dress-up kit.
IMAGE VIA AMAZON

One can’t love the mystery genre without reading the most famous detective series ever to have existed. (Unless they think Sherlock Holmes is overrated.) To feel like the greatest detective in literary media, dress up like him. Sherlock Holmes is iconic for his deerstalker cap and wooden pipe, and this dress-up kit includes two colored hats and a magnifying glass. This ensemble will complete the look your friend will love to impersonate.

If It’s Not a Thriller Mug

A white mug with a black-colored handle with a quote that says "If it's not a thriller I don't want it" with a shelf filled with books. There's a lit candle with books behind the mug.
IMAGE VIA ETSY

Get your friend or close relative this cute ceramic mug stating their reading preference. With their favorite drink, they can cover themselves with a blanket and suspense themselves in horror and thrilling mysteries. With a bold statement to complement the sweet cursive, “I don’t want it,” perfectly matches the tense mood of your friend’s reading time. 

Masquerade Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

The Masquerade Kit is designed with half a white pale face wearing a golden mask. A red cloak is floating by the kit with a jester-like mask and a candle.
IMAGE VIA MASTERS OF MYSTERY

If your friend loves hosting murder mystery parties, why not buy them this elegant masquerade ball-themed game kit? With the Carnival season starting in 1755 Venice, everyone in the city has their faces covered, which is the perfect disguise for murder. A figure in red is the poor soul whose life was stolen, found on the floor dead with broken glass beside the body. With no one knowing who this mysterious red figure was, it falls on the party to reveal who killed them. It’s the perfect gift if your loved one loves to dress up. The opportunity to live out elegant Venice with a mystery is guaranteed fun!

Six-Mystery Sherlock Holmes Bundle

Sherlock Holmes's Letter Kit is on the table with a coffee and a planted skull surrounding the letter.
IMAGE VIA DEAR HOLMES

If your friend or relative is a Sherlock Holmes fan, this is for them. If you buy them this gift, your friend will receive mailed letters from Sherlock Holmes. For six months, your friend will receive letters from Sherlock and his sidekick, James Watson, challenging them to solve a case with a new letter each week. The letter comes in a legit envelope with clues to help solve the case. This gift will stimulate your loved one with weekly anticipation if they’re known to agonize and obsess over every detail!

Listen For the Lie by Amy Tintera

Listen For the Lie by Amy Tintera book cover of a red-shadowed cover with a plug swirling around the title's letters.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP.ORG

If you want to give your mystery enthusiast a trusty book, no worries — this book will draw more than just their attention. Listen For the Lie follows Lucy and her dark past. Ten years ago, Lucy was discovered walking in her small Texas town covered in her best friend’s blood. Lucy and Savvy were the stars of the city, and everyone was jealous of them. But with Savvy’s death and Lucy’s apparent bloody hands in the crime, her reputation is tarnished. With a podcaster looking into Lucy’s forgotten memories of that night, will she want to know whether or not she did kill her best friend? Mystery lovers say “yes” to solving the case.

Danganronpa Decadence on the Nintendo Switch

"Danganronpa Decadence" for the Nintendo Switch game covers of different characters from the three main storylines with Monokuma at the bottom.
IMAGE VIA AMAZON

If your person loves playing video games, get them this interactive murder mystery. The setting is Hope’s Peak Academy, the exclusive school where talented students are destined to become Japan’s hope for the future. When a group of students are suspiciously held in the the school by the deranged teddy bear Monukuma, it’s up to them whether or not to enact the bear’s killing game. But with freedom on the line, the students will do whatever it takes to leave, even murder. Protagonist Makoto Naegi will step up to solve the crimes to stay alive. Guessing the wrong perpetrator is a guaranteed death for the whole class. This game will test patience, but solving who’s the murderer will be worth it.

I hope this gives you more ideas for what to give this holiday season! If you come up empty, there’s always a plethora of true crime podcasts and books to give to your loved ones!


For more gift guides, click here!

Interested in the mystery genre yourself? Click here for more options!

FEATURED IMAGE VIA BOOKSTR / CLAUDIA MALDONADO