Thomas Berger and the American Dream: Critiquing the Mythic Ideal

Let’s explore the life and works of Thomas Berger, focusing on his examination and deconstruction of the mythological ideal that has molded the American Dream.

Author's Corner Book Culture Classics Literary Fiction On This Day

The promise of endless possibility and success and riches is what has kept the American Dream alive in people’s imaginations for ages. Thomas Berger, a prominent American novelist, ventured to criticize the mythic ideal in his writings. Berger’s astute criticism of the American Dream casts doubt on the possibility of a paradise in which the pursuit of personal happiness is rewarded with financial plenty.

His work included novels, short tales, and plays, demonstrating his versatility as a writer. Berger was a talented man in many ways, but his best-known works stem from his exploration and reinvention of the American Dream. His work displayed a sharp wit, biting humor, and a fascination with the complexities of the human condition. Let’s explore Thomas Berger’s biography, his works, and the ways in which he expertly analyzed and debunked the mythological ideal that has molded American society.

Dismantling the Idolized Ideal

Throughout his acclaimed work Little Big Man, Thomas Berger takes the reader on a voyage of deep self-discovery as he dismantles the mythical ideal known as the American Dream. Berger deftly undermines the heroic founder stereotype and the limitless possibilities of the American West via Jack Crabb’s fascinating life story. The different eras of American history represented by Jack Crabb’s life provide a rich tapestry of insight into the reality of the American Dream.

Deftly navigating Crabb’s dealings with Native Americans, cowboys, outlaws, and pioneers, Berger reveals the many layers of humankind and the gloomier regions of American history that are obscured by the romanticized narrative. He compels readers to face difficult realities regarding the displacement and suffering of Native American tribes by rejecting the idealized concept of pioneers as heroes constructing a brighter future.

Dustin Hoffman and co-actor on the set of little Big Man

The exchanges between Crabb and historical characters like Wild Bill Hickok and General Custer help Berger debunk the heroes’ mythology. Berger portrays them as multifaceted humans with weaknesses and uncertain motivations rather than heroic figures whose deeds represent the American ideal. By doing so, he challenges our tendency to oversimplify the past and calls for a more nuanced view of the past’s most influential personalities.

Crabb’s adventures also include his time spent in California during the Gold Rush, when he saw firsthand the devastation and unrestrained greed that followed the rush to become rich. Berger explores the negative aspects of the American Dream, including the destruction of the environment, moral compromises, and societal chaos that emerge from unrestrained ambition and the pursuit of monetary achievement.

Dustin Hoffman sitting atop a horse on the set of Little Big Man movie.

In Little Big Man, Thomas Berger successfully dismantles the mythological vision of the American Dream, which holds that America is a paradise where everyone is free to pursue their own happiness and the sky’s the limit for them. Berger encourages the audience to critically think, wrestle with the intricacies of American history, and challenge the concepts and principles by which the American Dream is founded, rather than perpetuate an idealized picture of reality.

Within this dissection, Berger calls for an understanding of the American experience that is more comprehensive, one that takes into account the country’s many successes and failures. At the end of the book, he suggests we rethink the mythical pursuit of individual glory in favor of a vision of the American Dream that values social growth.

The Consumerist Madness in America

Thomas Berger’s Neighbors, a satirical masterwork, provides a harsh indictment of materialism, demonstrating how pointless it is to place a premium on material goods and signs of wealth. Berger explores the repercussions of unbridled materialism via a tale that is both grimly comic and ludicrous, illuminating the hollowness and superficiality that lay just beyond the surface of a culture that is obsessed with the accumulation of material items.

The plot centers on the Hansens and the Tuttles, two neighbors who appear comfortable with their mundane lives until a chance meeting shatters their tranquility. The Hansens are intrigued by the Tuttles after hearing a loud commotion coming from their next-door neighbors’ house. This mild interest quickly develops into a pathological obsession, and the Hansens begin an uneasy race with the Tuttles to outdo them in material wealth.


Berger uses the characters’ over-the-top antics to draw attention to the ridiculousness of materialism and its effects on individuals’ social and mental health. The protagonists are shown as captives of their own lusts and the false hope that wealth may bring. The main characters become more lonely and miserable regardless of their material success because of their incessant pursuit of more at the expense of true relationships and interactions.

Berger’s criticism is more than just personal; it’s a statement on our consumer-based culture as a whole. He discusses the ways in which advertising and marketers have manipulated society and consumer preferences. He does so to highlight the risks associated with basing one’s sense of self-worth on material goods and social standing rather than on one’s core principles and interpersonal connections.

The New American Dream

It is clear from Thomas Berger’s criticisms that reimagining the American Dream requires a radical change in emphasis from the traditional pursuit of personal monetary achievement to a more holistic and inclusive vision of prosperity. Berger, through his writings, casts doubt on the veracity of the conventional story that has for so long dominated American society.

He challenges us to reinvent a shared ideal that puts a premium on empathy, community, and a nuanced knowledge of history by tearing down the romanticized portrayal of pioneers and historical characters and underlining the negative effects of unbridled consumerism.

Berger’s potent criticisms encourage us to go beyond our narrow definitions of success and happiness, which place too much emphasis on individual achievement and possessions and instead consider how we may contribute to the greater good via our ties with one another and our empathy and compassion for those less fortunate. Consequently, if we want to reimagine the American Dream, we need to adopt a vision that is more caring and welcoming, one that acknowledges the complexity of our past and encourages a feeling of community. If we succeed in achieving this, we may create a future where the strength of our relationships and the advancement of everyone determine whether or not we are prosperous as a society, overcoming the constraints of the mythological ideal.

Berger’s writings provoke reflection by pointing out the fallacy of valuing monetary success above building meaningful relationships inside and beyond communities. Thomas Berger’s incisive observations are still a vital resource for thought and discussion as we delve further into the ever-shifting idea of the American Dream.

To read more about the American Dream, click here!