Mixed Reviews on the Latest Installment of the Tolkien World

There’s a new addition to the Tolkien franchise this holiday season and we have all the details. Read on to learn more!

Pop Culture Trending TV & Movies
A woman with red hair and a leafed headband looks forward. Her image is framed by a black film. To the left is a film camera against a yellow background with three yellow stars on top. The background is a mountain landscape.

If you’re a Lord of the Rings fan, we have some exciting news for you! One of the big film releases this holiday season is The War of the Rohirrim. The format is presented in a fresh, new look for Tolkien fans, since the movie is directed by anime creator Kenji Kamiyama, while Peter Jackson is still listed as a producer. The rest of the cast includes Brian Cox, Gaia Wise, and Luke Pasqualino, while Miranda Otto returns as the narrator.

The War of the Rohirrim promotional poster. A woman with battle armor wields a sword. In the background is a bearded man with a helmet and a dark-haired man with a fur cape. The sky is dark green with a bird flying overhead. A battle scene lines the bottom frame.
IMAGE VIA WARNER BROS.
Bookstr Promo Code ad for Bookshop.org — enter BOOKSTR10 at checkout for 10% off your order.

What’s the Plot?

The storyline takes place 183 years before the events of The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Reflecting Miranda Otto’s character in The Return of the King, this episode features a strong young woman named Héra, who stands up against a mighty patriarchy — her father, Helm Hammerhand, leader of Rohan. Tensions arise, Héra at the center of the drama, when the antagonist Wulf attempts to avenge his father’s death at the hands of Helm. While at the same time, Wulf is furious for being denied Héra as his wife.

A woman with red hair rides on a white horse. She carries a bow on her back. A forest is in the background.
IMAGE VIA WARNER BROS.

The Current Reception

With reviews rolling in, so far, this movie looks like one of those incidents where professional movie critics are not impressed, but the fans seem pleased by the latest Tolkien installment. Rotten Tomatoes’ audience score sits at a solid 83%. However, an article released by Forbes argues that Kamiyama’s film doesn’t make an impression among this year’s animated features.

An old man with long white hair and a beard sits on a throne. A man and a woman sit on each side of him. A fire is lit in a bowl in the background.
IMAGE VIA WARNER BROS.

The Independent also presents a negative opinion, blaming the rushed quality on Warner Brothers attempting to release the film as soon as possible in order to retain rights to Tolkien’s work. Among the negative feedback, there has been mention of the reuse of old audio from the 2000s movies, with an example of an archival recording of Christopher Lee as Saruman. In contrast, these throwbacks to previous installments, while not pleasing to the critics, can be delightful for the fans.

The War of the Rohirrim released in theaters on December 13th. Make sure you catch it on the big screen while you can for a chance to see this franchise in a different medium from what we’ve seen before.


Ever wonder which LOTR character you are? Then take this quiz to find out!

For some more fantasy recommendations, check out our bookshelf, Fantasy Lovers Paradise: Epics, Romances, and More!

FEATURED IMAGE VIA BOOKSTR / MONICA MENDEZ