Make Santa’s Naughty or Nice List With These Wonderful Romances

Have you been naughty or nice this year? This recommendations list can help you decide your fate on Santa’s list!

Recommendations Romance
Santa next to Hearts Overboard, Sunshine and Spice, and The Nightmare Before Kissmas.

Did you make the nice list this year? Or have you been naughty? If you read any of these romance books this year, it could be used as an indicator of which category you fall into. If you haven’t, well, it’s not too late to make it onto either list!

Sex, Lies and Sensibility by Nikki Payne

Sex, Lies and Sensibility by Nikki Payne. Orange cover with man and woman surrounded by fall leaves.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP.ORG

First up on the naughty reads list is Sex, Lies and Sensibility, a steamy romance based on Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility. Nora finds out she is the secret child of her father’s affair at the reading of his will, and inherits his inn. On the way is Ennis, or “Bear” as he’s known, who is looking to claim the property. The magnetic pull between Nora and Bear is undeniable, and the drama between the two is fantastic.

Sunshine and Spice by Aurora Palit

Sunshine and Spice by Aurora Palit. Bengali woman overlooking grumpy man in two windows.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP.ORG

In this grumpy/sunshine Bengali romance, Naomi Kelly and Dev Mukherjee begin fake dating to appease their parents and help the business Naomi is attempting to make successful. Naomi gets lessons in Bengali culture, and Dev gets to have his mother call off the arranged matchmaking. Sweet as it is spicy, Sunshine and Spice is sure to get you on Santa’s nice list.

The Nightmare Before Kissmas by Sara Raasch

The Nightmare Before Kissmas by Sara Raasch. Two men in winter clothes on Halloween and Christmas background.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP.ORG

A holiday book for the queer community, The Nightmare Before Kissmas stars Prince Nicholas “Coal” Claus of Christmas trying to escape the PR-laden Christmas his father, the current Santa, has created. However, despite his father trying to make him marry Iris the Easter Princess, Coal falls for his marriage rival, the Prince of Halloween, Hex. Sure to get you put on the naughty list for reading it because of behind-the-bar make-out sessions and more, The Nightmare Before Kissmas is the spicy read of the season.

Hearts Overboard by Becky Dean

Hearts Overboard by Becky Dean. Couple one ship in front of Alaskan landscape.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP

Sweet as sugar, Hearts Overboard puts the nice in a nice list. Savannah Moore is trying to get her ex Caleb to eat his words about her being boring. She does this by going on an Alaskan cruise with family friend Tanner, whom she hates. However, as Tanner helps her become more adventurous, love blossoms despite the cold. This sweet romance will satisfy your wanderlust and longing this holiday season.

If You Hate Me by Helena Hunting

If You Hate Me by Helena Hunting. Couple leaning back to back on blue cover with man holding ice skates.
IMAGE VIA BOOKSHOP.ORG

Rix and Tristian’s naughty escapades are sure to get any reader on the naughty list straight away. In If You Hate Me, Rix is caught in a roommate situation with Tristan, whom she loathes no less. Tristan is Rix’s brother’s best friend, adding to the tension between them as well. This sexy novel is memorable, fun, and heated without a doubt.

Whether you’ve been nice or naughty this year, these books pack a punch and should be on your TBR list if they aren’t already. Remember, Santa’s checking his list twice, so be sure to be on your best (or worst) behavior.


Ready for more romance? Check out this article.

Still aching for more love stories? Try our Love Is In The Air shelf on Bookshop.org!

FEATURED IMAGE BY SABRINA DELGADO/BOOKSTR