Tag: eBook

Forget About The eBook, At Least At Your Local Library

In this era of new-age technology overshadowing old-school technology, many readers have turned towards E-books to fulfill their desire for books. The everlasting battle of e-books versus printed books has been going on for years, psychologists and scientists examined the pros and cons of both.

News has just been released that puts the love for the e-book on a break as it turns out that Publishers across the country are hoping to increase sales for e-books by putting restrictions onto libraries.



For the book nerds out there who frequent their local library, if you’re hoping to download any e-books, a long wait is what you’ll be stuck with.


The Buffalo News put together a timeline of the slow domino effect that leads us to where we are today.

All of the limitations on library ebooks began this past June. Hachette Book Group started requiring that libraries pay for their ebooks every two years. After that other companies began to follow suit.


Image result for macmillan publishers

IMage via American Libraries Magazine


Macmillan Publishers, for example, has placed a limiting embargo on their newest releases. These ebooks will be purchased by libraries in the end, but they will have to wait eight weeks for that. Until then, libraries are left with two options.


The first is to either wait the eight weeks and then buy multiple copies of these e-books at a cost of $60 per copy, the library system would then gain the right to circulate each e-book copy, but only for two years. Option number two is to buy and circulate one copy of the newly released e-book right away, at a discounted cost of $30. That purchase would allow the system to circulate that single copy forever, but it would also mean initial wait times would explode since only a single copy would be available.


There is also the option for libraries to buy one $30 copy of the book right away, then buy more $60 copies after eight weeks, but that is a lot of money for a public institution.


Image result for textbooks and money

Image via The Red Pen


The argument that publishers are stating is that they were losing more money in their ebook sales, and that the restrictions and bans are a necessity, but Libraries are fighting back with a ban of their own by boycotting books from these publishers.


Macmillan is a big one that’s being boycotted, at least for its ebooks.


Image result for Melody Sky Eisler, director of the Port Townsend Public Library

Melody Sky Eisler, director of the Port Townsend Public Library | Image via Port TownsendLeader


The news publication, The Leader shared a statement from Melody Sky Eisler, director of the Port Townsend Public Library, on behalf of her library and the Jefferson County Library, about what the Cooperative Libraries of the Eastern Olympics (CLEO) have decided to do.


Public libraries promote equitable access to information and resources, while encouraging a lifelong love of reading, Eisler stated. However, publishers have recently moved to charge libraries significantly more for eBooks and eAudiobooks than regular consumers, requiring libraries to re-purchase materials after 24 months, and are now embargoing new publications for months at a time…

According to Eisler, this removes the ease of access that the city and county libraries strive to deliver to patrons — and taxpayers! — and incurs increased expenses for libraries.



With everything going on with these embargos, it may take several months before you can download any copy of a library’s ebook, that is if they’re chosen to have any at all.



Featured Image via Tech SME


Bookstr is community supported. If you enjoy Bookstr’s articles, quizzes, graphics and videos, please join our Patreon to support our writers and creators or donate to our Paypal and help Bookstr to keep supporting the book loving community.
Become a Patron!


Public Library Responds to Macmillan’s E-Book Controversy

In a draft of a memo sent to Macmillan authors, CEO of the publishing giant, John Sargent, wrote of a new plan to increase revenue made through e-book lending at libraries. “To balance the great importance of libraries with the value of [authors’] work,” Macmillan plans to sell only one copy of any newly-released e-book at $30 to any library. Libraries will then have to wait two months after the title’s release to purchase additional copies at $60.

For those of you who aren’t fluent in corporate-speak, this means Macmillan is essentially trying to squeeze more money out of libraries that already face overly-complicated licensing policies for e-books.


Seattle Public Library

Seattle Public LIbrary, Image via Thestranger.com


In some sense, this new arrangement should come as no surprise. E-books represent a dramatic challenge to the library lending model, and Sargent notes that digital lending is inherently more seamless and involves less friction than its physical counterpart. After all, what’s easier for the reader: traveling to a physical location to check out and return a physical copy or merely downloading an e-book from a library’s database? Still, these proposed changes which are scheduled to come in to effect November 1st have angered quite a few public libraries.



Marcellus Turner, chief librarian of the Seattle Public Library, chose to  respond to these changes in a statement on the library’s website.


Marcellus Turner

Marcellus Turner, Image via the Seattle Public LIbrary


The gist of his response:


  1. Macmillan’s new policy will severely affect the ability of library’s in dense, urban areas to meet their visitors’ needs.
  2. The policy will disproportionately affect readers with limited resources.
  3. Major publishers already charge an increased rate for library copies of e-books, and licensing agreements for e-book lending are already complicated. This change from Macmillan represents an even more restrictive shift in the publishing industry.


Turner ends his message by explaining that public libraries are highly committed to providing access for those that most need it, but Macmillan’s new policy makes that commitment much harder to maintain.


Andrew Harbison, assistant director of collections at access at the Seattle Public Library

Image Via Library as Incubator Project


In an interview with TheStranger.com, Andrew Harbison, assistant director of collections at access at SPL, took issue with Sargent’s claim that e-book lending cannibalizes e-book sales. Though the lending model may need to be re-examined, Harbison contended e-book lending may actually boost sales by “retaining, maintaining, and advocating for a robust reading culture.” Harbison also argued this change will reduce the quality of the collection a library can build, ultimately harming readers who depend on library services.

What do you think? Are Macmillan Publishers in the right for prioritizing their bottom line? Or should libraries be thought of as a public good rather than a money-making tool? Let us know on Facebook and Instagram!



Featured images via TheStranger.com and Seattle Public Library